Thursday, May 6, 2021

 Coming soon - the calendar of workshop events, hosted on EventBrite and delivered live via Zoom.

😎

Monday, April 23, 2012

Multi-Vari Studies, How to Quickly Find 85% of the Variation in a Product or Service


The name “Multi-Vari” was given to this form of analysis by L.A. Seder in his classic paper “Diagnosis with Diagrams,” which appeared in Industrial Quality Control in January and March 1950.  The premise is to utilize graphics to understand where the variation in a process exists.  Is it excessive variation within a single piece, excessive variation from piece to piece, or is the variation excessive from time to time.  If we are relating this to service delivery substitute “service delivery to customers”, “service delivery from customer to customer”, and “service delivery from time to time” in the previous sentence.

Multi-Vari Studies are often classified as either a “Nested Design” or a “Crossed Design.”  In the Nested Design the data is collected without making changes to the process to investigate where the variation is coming from.  It could be positional which is within piece variation, it could be cyclical which is consecutive piece-to-piece variation, or it could be temporal which is time-to-time variation such as day-to-day, or week-to-week.  The following graphic is an example where we are trying to find the source of process variation with regard to warp in a glass container.

Multi-Vari Nested Design Chart


From this Nested Design Multi-Vari Chart we can clearly see that Machine Section 7 is very different than any other section on the machine.  Section 7 becomes the target for variation reduction.  The question becomes, “Why is it so different than the rest of the machine?”

In the Crossed Design the plan is to test changes to the process in a balanced manner following an on or off strategy.  In the Crossed Design either 2 or 3 potential variation contributor process variables are studied at 2 different settings.  Analysis of Variance is often added as part of the study to provide detailed statistics that support what the graphic analysis portrays.  The ANOVA provides the verdict of “guilty beyond a shadow of a doubt” to support what we see graphically.  The following graphic is an example where we are trying to minimize the time it takes to boil a cup of water in a microwave oven.

Multi-Vari Crossed Design Chart


From this Crossed Design Multi-Vari Chart it is clear that to minimize the time to boil a cup of water in a microwave oven the container should be rotated, located 4 inches off center, and covered.  To add further proof to this graphic finding an ANOVA (analysis of variance) was conducted with the following results.

Analysis of Variance ANOVA Table


The sources of variation are Cover, Rotate, and Location.  Each are significant with p values that are less than .0009 (assume worst case for unknown digit of 9) which equates to a confidence level of at least of 99.91%.

Multi-Vari Studies provide a graphic means to quickly find 85% of the variation in a product or service.  I think you will find this technique to be useful.

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

What is the difference between Process Sigma and Process Capability?


In both cases of Process Sigma and Process Capability we are talking about performance relative to the Customer’s requirements.  Is there a difference?  Is one measure better than the other?  These are good questions which you will be able to answer by reading on.

The difference between the Six Sigma metric of Process Sigma and Process Capability relates to the definitions of these performance metrics.  In both cases the Customer Specifications are compared to process performance.  For metrics that can be measured on a continuous scale the process mean and standard deviation must be calculated.  If the metrics from the process are discrete, or attributes, then the percent defective is calculated.  In either case the process performance as measured on a control chart should exhibit only natural random patterns of variation, or what is often called common cause variation over time.

Process Sigma
Process Sigma is defined by numeric levels that are related to a process’s output of defects per million opportunities.  Defects are defined as any failure to meet the customer’s specifications.  Process yield is used to look up the Process Sigma level from a table.  Yield is based on Defects (D), Units Processed (N), and the number of Opportunities (O) for a defect to occur.  Once the yield is calculated the Process Sigma can be found in the table below.
Formula for Process Yield
Process Sigma Level Conversion Table
Find the Process Sigma level in the table above.

If the process output can be measured on a continuous scale the process average and standard deviation are used in a formula that compares the average to the closest specification, whether it is the Upper Specification or the Lower Specification we choose the one closest to the process average.  Basically we are making this a one sided specification.  The standard normal distribution is used to estimate the defect rate which can then be converted to yield and use the above table to look up the Process Sigma level.
The other method is to calculate the Z statistic which estimates the number of standard deviation units the average is away from the closest specification which is based on the standard normal distribution.  We then add a 1.5 sigma shift to the calculated Z statistic which gives us the Process Sigma level directly.  The 1.5 sigma shift has been a matter of contention, but it is part of the definition of Process Sigma.  The following is the formula.
Formula for Process Sigma
The definition of Process Sigma is that at a level of 6 on the scale there will be only 3.4 defects per million opportunities.  The process is assumed to remain stable over time and if it drifts in one direction at a time of 1.5 sigma there will be no more than 3.4 defects per million under the tail of the distribution outside of the Customer’s Specification.  When we calculate the Z statistic we add the 1.5 sigma shift to give us the Process Sigma level directly.

Process Capability
Process Capability assessment begins with control charts to evaluate the stability over time for the process.  For the Process Capability study to be meaningful the process must exhibit only common cause variation, which are natural patterns of random variation.

In the case of Attribute, or discrete variables, data the Process Capability becomes the centerline of the Control Chart, or the average p, c, or u depending upon the chart being used.  In the example below the average p, or fraction non-conforming, is 0.076, or 7.6% defective.  The chart is in statistical control so the capability is the overall process average of percent defective.
P Chart exhibitting only common cause variation
In the case of continuous variables data the mean and standard deviation from the stable, or in statistical control, process comes into play.  We will describe 2 of the many Process Capability Indices.  The first is the Cp which compares total process variation to the total width of the specification.  The second is Cpk which takes into consideration centering of the process within the specification so we look at ½ of the process variation compared to the closest specification limit.

The Cp formula below divides the specification width by the measured process spread of 6 standard deviations.  A fully capable process has a Cp = 1.33 or greater.
Formula for Cp Capability Index
The Cpk formula below divides the absolute value of the difference between the process average and the closest specification by ½ of the measured process spread of 3 standard deviations.  A fully capable process has a Cpk = 1.33 or greater.
Formula for Cpk Capability Index
The Cp value indicates how capable a process can become if it is perfectly centered.  The Cpk value indicates how much work is needed to get centered.  In the following table notice that for a Cpk = 1.33 the Process Sigma = 5.5.  A process that operates at a Process Sigma = 6 has a Cpk = 1.50.  The Z Value is the number of standard deviation units away from the specification when the data is converted to a standard normal distribution.
Formula for Z Value
Table of conversions from Z to Cpk and Process Sigma.
Conversion table Z Value to Cpk to Process Sigma
Both measures of performance use that same statistics to be computed.  Whether you prefer Process Capability or Process Sigma the key is to apply the metrics consistently.  To be valid your process must be in a state of statistical control and exhibit only common cause variation.

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

SIPOC Approach to As Is Analysis


SIPOC is an acronym that stands for Suppliers, Inputs, Process Steps, Outputs, and Customers.  This high level process mapping method is ideal for diagnosing and analyzing the current state, or As Is condition of any business process.  The following outlines the SIPOC approach to As Is analysis and improvement solution identification.

The first task is to assemble a small team, 3-5 people, who play roles within the process under analysis that are familiar with the activities that take place within the process.  You may find that this team collectively knows the process from end to end even if some of the team members individually do not.  The team identifies the one key performance metric that defines success or failure for the process.

SIPOC Process Map


SUPPLIERS are the functional groups that provide the essential ingredients for the process to perform.  Create this list may include actual supplier companies that are contracted for goods and services as well as the internal groups and individuals that provide the things that make the process tick.  You may miss a few initially, but you can always add suppliers during the process mapping activity when they are identified.  If the process needs something, which Supplier provides it?

INPUTS are the essential ingredients provided by the Suppliers.  Those ingredients could be materials, goods, services, data, instructions, decisions, documents, analyses, or whatever the process requires.  For each Supplier make a list of all the inputs they provide.

PROCESS STEPS are the 5 high level steps from the beginning to the final outcome for the process.  Start with Step 1 and Step 5.  That defines the end to end scope of the As Is process analysis.  You can think of the process steps as the 5 key value stream steps.  Fill in Steps 2 through 4 after Step 1 and 5 are defined.  The performance metric should be measureable at Step 5 to determine process success or failure.

OUTPUTS are the result of each individual step in the process.  After completing Step 1 what is the thing that is generated by this process step.  In some cases a process step may have multiple outputs.  When you list the outputs they are in groups associated with their respective process step and should flow in order from 1 through 5.

CUSTOMERS are the recipients of the process outputs.  The process step generates something and it goes to a functional group which is either internal to the process or external to the process.

With the SIPOC Process Map completed the team collectively has a better overall understanding of the process from end to end.  Now is the time to challenge the process to identify where the issues are.  What are the causes of either success or failure based on the key performance metric?  Brainstorm using the Cause and Effect, or Fishbone Diagram.  This technique identifies the potential causes of the process issues.

To develop solutions the SCAMPER brainstorming technique is very useful.  In this structured method the SCAMPER acronym is used to challenge the process for improvements by asking what could be Substituted, Changed, Adapted or Amplified, Modified, Put to other uses, Eliminated, or Replaced / Removed / Rearranged.  Now you know the SIPOC approach to As Is analysis and improvement solution identification.

Monday, September 5, 2011

Designing Environmental Sustainability Programs using Process Design for Six Sigma


Environmental Sustainability is in the best interest of the Global Economy and Global Corporate Citizenship.  More and more companies are global in nature especially when you consider their supply chains and the total life cycle of their goods and services.  Environmental consciousness is increasing in importance and a key for competing in the global economy.

Customizing your company’s approach to defining and applying environmental best practices requires a systematic approach for process design.  Process Design for Six Sigma (DFSS) follows a five phased approach, namely Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, and Validate (DMADV).

The Define Phase is the Development Project Definition.  In this phase the scope, or depth and breadth, of the Environmental Sustainability Program is defined.  Here is where the resources are committed to the project, the project is planned, and the review points with specific deliverables are defined.

The Measure Phase is Requirements Definition.  In this phase the Voice of the Customer (VOC) is captured which in turn is translated in the requirements for the Environmental Sustainability Program.  The VOC comprises your suppliers, your company, your customers, and the countries where you conduct business.  This comprehensive view of the VOC requirements drives the right sizing of the program.  A Functional Model of what Environmental Sustainability has to accomplish and provide is aligned and prioritized using the VOC.  At this stage requirements are fully defined
.
The Analyze Phase is better described as the Conceptual Design.  What must be accomplished to meet the VOC has been documented with the prioritized functional model.  To meet the functional requirements processes are designed at the conceptual level using the SIPOC (Suppliers, Inputs, Process Steps, Outputs, and Customers) Process Mapping method.  In this method only five process steps are addressed which keeps the maps at a high level.  Information System requirements are defined to support each SIPOC Process that has been designed.  Performance Metrics are also defined.  Estimates of cycle frequency, cycle time, and staffing for each SIPOC all also determined.  Organizational requirements are conceptualized as well.

The Design Phase is Detailed Design.  The conceptual designs are now converted into detailed process maps.  This is the future state design of the Environmental Sustainability Program’s processes for execution.  Pilot testing takes place at this stage along with finalizing organizational requirements.  Work instructions, procedures, and policies are documented for efficient execution of the processes that will drive the Environmental Sustainability Program.

The Validate Phase is the final phase of DMADV.  In this phase the new processes go through final testing and debugging of support systems, validation of performance metrics, and implementation on a full scale.

Process Design for Six Sigma is the structured approach for any organization to determine just what Environmental Sustainability means for them.  Process DFSS guides the development of the processes that will meet your Environmental Sustainability goals and objectives.

Going Green with Six Sigma


The efficient approach to Going Green for any company is to follow the five phased DMAIC improvement process of Six Sigma.  Going Green can mean different things to different organizations.  You will have to define what Going Green means for your organization.
Defining your problems with waste management and setting your goals for waste reduction and savings is the first step.  The structured approach of the Define Phase in a Six Sigma project is the best approach to accomplish this.  The deliverables are your Problem Statement, Goal Statement, Constraints, Assumptions, Guideline’s for the Team, Green Requirements, and a Project Plan.  Types of waste that are often tackled are:
  • Cardboard,
  • Wood Pallets and Crates,
  • Banding,
  • Plastic,
  • Rags,
  • Cans and Bottles,
  • Paper,
  • Metal,
  • and Hardware. 
For these types of waste establish the baseline of Total Pounds of Waste, the Good is Recycled Pounds, the Bad or Defect is Land Fill Pounds.  Use this to set your process yield and process sigma level in the Measure Phase.

The Measure Phase for Going Green is all about establishing how you will measure your waste as previously defined and establishing your organization’s baseline performance.  Without the baseline performance you won’t be able to measure the green impact and savings from your Going Green Six Sigma Project.  One approach is analogous to the Mass Balance equation where Mass is conserved between inputs and outputs which must remain equal.

The Mass Balance Equation
Total of Material and Consumables Input = Output of Saleable Goods and Services + Waste to Atmosphere + Waste to Water Supply + Waste to Landfill + Hazardous Waste + Recyclables 
Your organization will have to determine the extent to apply this equation.

In the Analyze Phase the Team evaluates the waste categories and how and where they are created.  Is it a process issue, a policy issue, or just that we have always treated waste that way?  Once you understand where it is coming from then you can develop the creative solutions that will transform landfill waste into recyclable waste.  Depending upon the scope of the project the team may also be addressing other waste components of the mass balance equation.

In the Improve Phase the Team investigates alternatives for how to handle the multiple waste categories and how to minimize their creation.  Many items that were always sent to the landfill if separated can become recyclable.  In many cases recyclables can generate revenue.  The costs of storage and hauling can then be reduced.  This in turn changes the ratios of Total Waste to Recyclable Waste and to Landfill Waste.  Going Green has cost reduction and revenue enhancement benefits.

In the Control Phase the Team implements the policies, procedures, and work instructions to handle the waste categories.  Arrangements are made with waste and recycling organizations to handle the waste categories per the improvements identified.  Ongoing measurements are put in place to continue to drive landfill waste reduction and increase recyclables.  Similarly if the project scope was larger the other categories of waste would be included as well.  This is how Going Green is accomplished with the Six Sigma DMAIC approach to solving problems.

Friday, July 22, 2011

Tracking Performance over Time


Tracking performance over time can be accomplished using either one of two methods which are Run Charts or Control Charts.  Both methods use time as the baseline and the performance measure as the measurement that is tracked over time.  The major differences in the methods relate to the measures of demarcation on the charts.  Run Charts have a center line that represents the mid point of the measurement that is being tracked.  Control Charts have a center line that represents the average of the measurement that is being tracked and lines above and below the centerline that are estimates of 3 standard deviations about the average of the measurements.
Run Chart and Control Chart compared

In both of the charts time is the X axis.  The data is plotted in succession over time.  The charts can be segmented by specific time periods such as setting the baseline and after improvements have been implemented.  You will easily see the before and after results.  We can measure the difference between the before average and the after average to calculate the magnitude of the improvement.

Control Chart with Before and After Results

Tracking of performance is also a control for maintaining the gains from the improvements.    The Run Chart or the Control Chart provides a method to continuously evaluate performance and point out when corrective actions should be taken or when the process should be left alone.

Whenever we contemplate improving a process the baseline for the critical performance metric(s) must be established before any corrective actions are taken.  By doing this you will always be able to evaluate the impact of the improvements by measuring from the baseline to the future state of process performance.  In the rare case where the corrective action doesn’t work the tracking charts will point that out quickly so an alternative action can be taken.  I am sure that you can remember when a great idea just did not work so it is always best to track performance to validate the actual impact of our improvement efforts.

Sunday, July 17, 2011

Performance Measurement

Measuring performance is the key for driving dramatic improvements in any organization.  Choosing the right performance measures, or metrics, is essential to hone the focus of improvement project teams.
The key to honing the focus for the project team is to select measurements that are relevant to the level of the organization that is being impacted by the improvement project.  If the team is working on improvements at the work cell, or production line level within the organization having measurements that resonate with the Corporate Level of the organization won’t make much sense.  The measures must be selected that are appropriate for the level of the organization where the improvements are being made.
Examples of performance measures and the level within the organization follow:
Corporate Level
  • Return on Net Assets
  • Market Share
  • Total Stockholder Return
  • Capacity Utilization
  • Economic Value Added
Division Level
  • Customer Loyalty
  • Target Cost Attainment
  • Market Share by Division
  • Order Fulfillment Cycle Time
Business Unit Level
  • Business Unit Revenue
  • Business Unit Margin
  • Quality Cost
  • Process Efficiency
  • Staffing Plan Attainment
Work Cell / Production Line
  • Cycle Time
  • Process Yield
  • Employee Satisfaction
  • Outgoing Quality
A rating scale can be used to help with selecting the Key Performance Metric, or the CTQ (Critical to Quality) Metric, that will drive the improvement at the given level within the organization.  The rating scale follows:
Rating Scale for Performance Measures
Relevance
  1. Not at all linked to strategic objectives
  2. Poorly linked to strategic objectives
  3. Indirectly linked to strategic objectives
  4. Strongly linked to strategic objectives
  5. Directly linked to strategic objectives
Usefulness
  1. Too detailed to provide useful information
  2. Rarely provides useful information
  3. Occasionally provides useful information
  4. Usually provides useful information
  5. Constantly provided useful information
Understandability
  1. Very complex, hard to understand
  2. Understandable with study
  3. Neutral
  4. Fairly easy to understand
  5. Very easy to understand
Availability of Data
  1. Would be very difficult to obtain
  2. Will have to be measured manually
  3. Can be obtained by combining information on different reports
  4. Can be easily derived from information on existing reports
  5. Currently available from existing reports
Overall Average Score
  1. Extremely poor indicator / motivator
  2. Poor indicator / motivator
  3. Average indicator / motivator
  4. Good indicator / motivator
  5. Excellent indicator / motivator
The metric with the highest overall score should be used to drive, monitor, and maintain the gains form the improvement efforts.  Choosing the right performance measures is the key for driving dramatic improvements in any organization.

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Control Strategy that Works

Maintaining the gains from operations improvements is challenging, but not insurmountable.  It all starts at the beginning of your improvement project before you have made any changes.  The following steps are a guide to make your improvements stick!
  • Before and After Measurements
    • Pick one key performance metric that resonates with the process personnel.
    • Establish your baseline performance before making improvements or changing anything.
    • Track the performance over time for this one metric with a control chart or a run chart to show the before, during, and after improvement stages for the process.
  • Operational Definitions
    • Document what was changed or improved
    • Document the steps taken for the corrective actions that drove the improvement
    • Update or develop work instructions that clearly describe how to do the impacted process activities correctly and consistently.
    • Make sure that the work instructions, or procedures, are U-SMART (Useful, Specific, Measureable, Not Ambiguous, Repeatable, and Terse and to the point).
  • Control Plan
    • Name the owner of the process.
    • Identify where and who will measure your key performance metric.
    • Determine the frequency of measurements and updating of the tracking mechanism (control chart or run chart).
    • If something goes wrong name the corrective action takers.
    • Make a list of corrective action steps based upon the corrective actions that have already been implemented to resolve the past performance issues.
    • Keep all measurements, work instructions, process procedures, and corrective action steps visible for all process personnel to have ready access.
You can now run your process and maintain the gains from your improvements.  The Control Strategy that Works starts and ends with the measurement system.  We know where we are before we make changes and then validate the gains after implementation of corrective actions.  Keep on measuring to maintain those gains!

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Design of Experiments Process


The objectives for conducting a designed experiment are the following:
  • Find the most important factors/variables affecting a response(s).
  • Determine the best settings to improve the response(s) for the important factors.
  • Determine the cost effective settings for the factors that are not important.
  • Provide the required information in a timely, efficient and cost effective manner.
The Elements of an Experiment

The Design of Experiments Process

Benefits
  • Manufacturing Cost Savings
    • Scrap
    • Inspection
    • Rework Losses
    • Capital Material
    • Variation
  • Design Cost Savings
    • Delivery Cycle
    • Engineering Design Charges
    • Assembly Material, Labor and Overhead
    • Total Product Cost
  • Marketing Cost Savings
    • Properly allocate resources
    • Stop spending on Promotions that Don’t Work
    • Better understand what makes Customers choose your business
Key Strengths
  • Robustness against uncontrollable factors
  • Obtains required information in a cost effective manner
  • Identifies factors for cost savings
  • Results are reproducible
  • Can improve quality without incurring capital and material cost increases
  • Separates the Vital Few from the Trivial Many
To get started we offer a Design of Experiments Basics Course

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Functional Cost Modeling


There are two pieces to a Functional Cost Model.  The first is the Functional Model of the product or process.  The second is a comprehensive cost analysis which includes material, labor, allocated expenses, allocated assets, production processing and supporting processes, outsourcing, shipping, installation, service, warranty, and end of life.  After these two components have been created blending them together yields the Functional Cost Model.

The Functional Model
A functional model comprises the Prime Function, Tier 1, Tier 2, and in some cases Tier 3 sub-functions.  The Prime function for a product, or a service, describes in 10 to 15 words or less just what the product or the service is supposed to do.  Once that “What” for the prime function has been nailed down then the question becomes “How” is the “What” achieved.
The Tier 1 functions provide how statements required to achieve the prime function.  Then the Tier 1 functions become the “What” has to be achieved and the Tier 2 functions provide the how statements.  This “What” “How” relationship continues until the functional tree is completed.

Functional Model for an Elevator System

For processes the functional tree usually gets to the third tier where the process steps are reached.  For products the tiers may go beyond the third tier, or as far as needed until the BOM elements, production process steps, systems, installation processes, or servicing processes are reached.  The BOM elements can be a system, sub-system, or an individual component.

Comprehensive Cost Analysis
If a process is being analyzed each step in the process requires a complete cost breakdown from the customer demand for the service to final delivery of services and any remedial activities.
If a product is being analyzed the data includes all of the costs from product conception to end of product life.  The complete supply chain must be considered.  All outsourced activities must be considered.

Functional Cost Model
The final step in Functional Cost Modeling is gluing the Functional Model and the Comprehensive Cost Analysis together.  Costs are assigned to the Functional Model at the appropriate level whether BOM, process, system, sub-system, or other activity.
Once the functional cost model is complete, roll up the costs, look for the high cost functions, and then attack the high cost functions for possible ways to reduce the costs.  The functional requirements for a product or a service are driven by the voice of the customer.  How we choose to deliver those functions is where the creativity comes into play with the design and thus the cost.
The functional cost model is the basis for the Product Cost Reduction Process and Process Design for Six Sigma.

Friday, May 27, 2011

Ten Different Kinds of Errors


  1. Forgetfulness, because we just weren’t concentrating.  Avoided by checking at regular intervals.
  2. Lack of Understanding, where we jump to the wrong conclusion before becoming familiar with the situation.  Avoided by standardized work instructions and training.
  3. Identification Errors, where we view things too quickly or are too far away to see it clearly.  Avoided by training, vigilance, and just plain paying attention.
  4. Errors made by Amateurs, where the lack of experience gets in the way of doing things correctly.  Avoided by standardized operations and skill building.
  5. Willful Errors, which are often caused by poor judgment, ignoring rules, and taking shortcuts.  Avoided by basic education, training, and experience.
  6. Inadvertent Errors, where we take a mental vacation and absentmindedly make mistakes without even noticing that we did.  Avoided by paying attention, discipline, and standardized operations.
  7. Errors caused by Slowness, where our actions are slowed by delays in judgment.  We just weren’t sure what to do next.  Avoided by building skills and standardized operations.
  8. Errors caused by Lack of Standards, where mistakes are made because specifications, requirements, and instructions aren’t suitable or available.  Avoided by standardized operations, policies, procedures, and work instructions.
  9. Surprise Errors, where the process just isn’t running as expected.  Avoided by preventive maintenance, productive maintenance, and standardized operations.
  10. Intentional Errors, where a few people deliberately make mistakes as in crimes and sabotage.  Avoided by fundamental education and discipline.

Poka Yoke five best practices for Process and Design are:
Process
  1. Guide pins (location and/or size)
  2. Error detection and alarms
  3. Limit switches
  4. Counters
  5. Checklists
Design
  1. Self fixturing
  2. Multi-functional parts
  3. Minimizing part variation
  4. Symmetrical parts
  5. In-sensitive to part variation
Utilizing the best practices of Poka Yoke can lead the way for your work environment to achieve zero defects.

Thursday, May 26, 2011

SMED for Setup Reduction


SMED is an acronym that stands for Single Minute Exchange of Die.  The systematic approach to reaching this nirvana was developed by Shigeo Shingo in the spring of 1950 at Toyo Kogyo’s Mazda plant in Hiroshima, Japan.  He defined a new way of looking at the structure of production by focusing on the relationship between processes and operations.  Here is how to do it.
Shingo defined Processes as:
  • Work
  • Inspection
  • Transportation
  • Storage
Shingo defined Operations as:
  • Setup Operations
    • Preparation
    • After Adjustments
  • Principal Operations
    • Main Tasks
    • Incidental Tasks
  • Marginal Allowances
    • Fatigue
    • Hygiene
    • Operations
    • Workplace
SMED for Setup Reduction is comprised of four phases.
Phase 1
This is the as-is, or current state, situation for the production process where both internal and external setup operations are considered to be the same.  There is no separation.  To understand how to make the distinction between internal and external setup operations requires the capture of baseline information and data.
To get the data and information you can:
  • Conduct work sampling,
  • Conduct interviews with the process participants,
  • but the best method is to videotape, or digitally record an entire setup from start to finish.
Phase 2
Now that the baseline has been established the task is to identify and separate the internal and external setup operations.
Definitions:
Internal Setup Operations
  • What operations for setup must be performed when the equipment or process has to be idle?
External Setup Operations
  • What are the operations for setup that can be performed while current production is taking place before the equipment or process must be shut down and thus idle?
The key to achieving SMED is the ability to distinguish between internal and external setup.
Phase 3
Now that the setup operations have been classified as either internal or external operations it is time to convert internal to external aggressively.  Baseline setup times can be reduced by 30% to 50% or more and this is just the beginning.  Go for it and get even more reductions!
How?
  • Make all the conversions identified in Phase 2.
  • Was anything wrongly classified as internal?
  • Can any of the internal operations be converted to external?
  • What do you mean it can’t be done?  Go for it!
Phase 4
Streamline all aspects of both internal and external setup operations.   In this phase look at each of the operations for setup and look for ways to improve them and reduce the time required to get them done.  Nirvana is Single Minute Exchange of Die.  You might not get there that that is the goal!
Phases 3 and 4 can be worked concurrently.  Shigeo Shingo developed this method, SMED, over a period of nineteen years through examining the theoretical and practical aspects of setup improvement.  He developed the cookbook.  It is up to you to apply it.

Monday, May 2, 2011

Supply Chain Optimization by applying Lean and Six Sigma

A company’s supply chain is its lifeblood.  The opportunities for improvement and change are numerous once identified.  To dramatically improve the speed, flexibility, and cost of the supply chain requires a structured and systematic approach.  Our proven approach follows the DMAIC Six Sigma operations improvement process, integrates Lean principles, and includes the DMADV Design for Six Sigma process as well.
The following outline describes at a high level how to achieve Supply Chain Continuous Improvement.
  1. Mobilize for Improvement and DEFINE the Opportunities
    1. Systematically evaluate and select opportunities focusing on tangible improvement
    2. Build and train teams assigned to specific improvement projects
  2. MEASURE, Monitor, and Analyze Performance
    1. Performance Measurement Indentification
    2. Performance Measurement Tracking
    3. Performance Measurement Monitoring and Analysis
  3. ANALYZEand Diagnose the Supply Chain
    1. Design of Products and Processes DFSS (Excellence, Assembly, Manufacturability, Installation, Service, and Reliability)
    2. Supply of Raw Materials and Components
    3. Conversion and Production
    4. Fielded Product Reliability and Customer Feedback
  4. IMPROVEthe Processes, Products, and Service Delivery
    1. Establish and Implement the Required Actions
  5. CONTROLthe Processes, Products, and Service Delivery
    1. Quality Management System
    2. Monitor the Steady State
Process Predictability Management has applied this process to numerous supply chains with dramatic results.  We can both teach and guide your team to apply these methods to your supply chain.  If you are serious about dramatic and continuous improvement contact us.  We are here to help.

Friday, April 15, 2011

Multiple Regression Analysis


Multiple Regression Analysis can be a powerful tool for evaluation of multiple process, or product inputs versus a single output characteristic which is often a balanced scorecard element.  The results can provide insight into what makes a difference, what doesn’t make a difference, and unfortunately the just can’t tell.

The keys to the analysis boil down to the structuring of your data set for the multiple regression.  A common stratification factor that aligns all of the data elements is paramount and the most common one is the date that is associated with the data elements, both the input X’s and the output Y.  If some data is missing for a particular date the best practice is to remove all of the data elements for that date from the model.  Maintaining balance is critical.

Before throwing all of the data into a multiple regression analysis using a statistical analysis package such as JMP or Minitab look at the data graphically with a matrix scatterplot.  Look for relationships, either positive or negative, that relate an input X with the output Y.  Also, be wary of highly correlated X to X relationships.  That could be colinearity, which can lead to misinterpretation of your regression model.

The graphic look at the relationships will point out the X variables that don’t need to be included in the model to start with.  During the multiple regression analysis multicolinearity can be dealt with using variance inflation factors (VIFs) which require values of 5 or less.  Depending on the statistics software package during the first iteration of your regression model you will be presented with T statistics or F statistics.  These statistics are used to generate the all important p values. 

Pooling is the elimination of the non-significant variables.  The first step in reduction of variables is to identify the X’s that have either F<=1 or absolute value of T<=1.  These must be removed from the model.  Now re-run the regression model and check the VIFs.  Typically any VIFs that are greater than 5 can be removed based upon having a large p value.  The caution here is to take them out one at a time and rerun the model.  I forgot to tell you, that is why it is called multiple regression analysis, you will be doing this multiple times.

Now that your regression model has been reduced to the significant X’s you should have the following.

  • X variables have p values less than 0.05.
  • R squared is 65% or greater.
  • VIFs are all less than 5.

The next question after all of this work has been completed is, “Do the relationships in the model make sense?”  Use your process and product knowledge to give the results a sanity check.  If it makes sense than you are ready to use the mathematical model developed to make predictions.  The conservative approach is to stay within the minimum and maximum values for each of the significant X variables that were used to develop your model, remember that is the only data that you have and is the basis for the model.

Here is why.  There was a study done in Oslo.  The population of storks was increasing along with the number of babies being born which is a strong positive correlation.  Therefore, we can declare that Storks bring Babies!  The truth is, storks nest near warm chimneys so as the population was growing more houses were built, more chimneys, and thus more nesting places for the birds.  Remember, you’re a priori knowledge about products, processes, and services should be used to give your multiple regression model results a sanity check.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Process Design for Six Sigma Course

The Process Design for Six Sigma Course will teach you the DMADV five phased approach to new process development. The five phases of the DMADV approach are Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, and Validate.

To facilitate the course we follow an actual new process being developed, a Quality Management System, step by step using the Process Design for Six Sigma method. You will see first hand how the deliverables lead to the creation of the new process.

You will be provided a set of tools that can be used to develop a new process following the DFSS, Design for Six Sigma methodology. The course features animations, videos, interactive quizzes, and a final exam. The course takes about 3 hours and 10 minutes of total seat time. No module within the course is longer than 30 minutes. There are 20 modules in this course which includes 6 quizzes and a final exam.

Course Outline

  • Introduction
    • Course Outline
    • Introduction and Overview
    • Process DFSS Toolkit Downloads
    • Process DFSS Roadmap Video
    • Introduction Quiz
  • Process DFSS Course
    • Define Phase
    • Define Quiz
    • Measure Phase
    • CTQ Tree Video
    • Voice of Customer QFD Video
    • Function Analysis Video
    • Measure Quiz
    • Analyze Phase
    • Analyze Quiz
    • Design Phase
    • Design Quiz
    • Validate Phase
    • Validate Quiz
  • Process DFSS Course Wrap Up
    • DMADV Deliverables Review
    • Final Exam

This course is priced at $200. A bargain for learning how to develop new processes that will meet and exceed customer requirements. Register Today!

Monday, February 7, 2011

Measurement System Analysis – Is it important?

Just how reliable is your data? Everyday, devices are used to measure things and give us the data. Colleagues evaluate things and make decisions about goodness and badness. Then, all this information ends up in a computer where the data can be crunched and plotted using a software tool. We can then evaluate the results and make those all important data driven decisions. That’s what we want to do, but what if the data isn’t reliable?

To answer that question the often overlooked Measurement System Analysis (MSA) comes into play. We can all agree that using data and statistics to guide our decision making process makes sense. Assuring that our data has integrity is therefore highly important. That is just what a MSA can do for you.

MSA can be applied whether the measurements are taken with a device or assessed based upon some criteria. For the data to be considered reliable for use in a statistical analysis for making decisions it must be captured by a process that is repeatable and reproducible. Repeatable means that if I evaluate the same item multiple times I will get the same answer each time. Reproducible means that if you, me, and your best friend were to evaluate the same item multiple times we would all get the same answer each time.

The reliability of our data is very important because taking corrective actions or making data driven decisions can make or break an organization. It gets back to the old saying, “If it ain’t broke don’t fix it.” The MSA study does take a little time and some planning. It is basically a hypothesis test to determine if the measurement system can determine if there is a difference or not. We want to prove that all the variation in the data is associated with the differences in the items being evaluated, not in the measurement system that is being used for the evaluation.

Time and again we have found that the first place to take corrective action in a process is the measurement system itself. Be wary of data that came from the information system. Just how did that data get into the system in the first place? Make sure that time is aligned with the data. Measurement System Analysis is important, especially if you want to make good business decisions based upon data.

Saturday, December 18, 2010

Sales and Marketing Six Sigma - If not now, then when?

Sales and Marketing is the process of converting the efforts of the company into revenue. The Process should create value in the market place by differentiating the products and services of the company versus your competitor’s alternatives resulting in prospects becoming customers. The Six Sigma approach to improving any business process follows the DMAIC Improvement Process namely Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control. Organizations that are embracing this approach have realized productivity increases, cost reductions, and revenue stream enhancement. Success has been proven in operations, production, and service delivery. It is now time to rollout Six Sigma DMAIC in Sales and Marketing.

Ask yourself if your organization is facing any of the following issues:

  • Competitor inroads into clients markets.
  • Disappointing sales growth.
  • Failure to crack key new markets.
  • New product introduction difficulties.
  • Unreliable or insufficient information re:customers, competitors, market conditions, etc.
  • Low, static, or declining market share.
  • Selling expenses growing as percent of sales revenue.
  • Low sales force morale, productivity.

Any of the above issues can be tackled as a Six Sigma DMAIC improvement project.

  • It starts when we Define the issue with a SMART problem and objective statement. (specific, measureable, achievable, relevant, and time based)
  • Then select which Key Performance Metrics (KPMs) to Measure that establish a baseline to track improvement. Measure the KPMs and establish how big, how bad, and how often the issue impacts the KPMs.
  • Next, Analyze the data and quantify the root causes that impact the KPMs.
  • Develop creative solutions that address the root causes and will Improve the KPMs. Validate the solutions through pilot testing and evaluation of measurements versus the baseline performance.
  • Develop and implement Control that will maintain the gains and put ownership at the source. Ramp the solutions up to full scale to meet customer demand. This is the DMAIC improvement process, namely Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control.

Six Sigma DMAIC can be applied whether the improvement project scope can be accomplished in days, weeks, or months.

Friday, November 26, 2010

Keys to Successful Operations Improvement

Operations improvement is not magic, but strategically focused hard work. The keys to successful operations improvement include these five elements:

  • Performance Metrics tied to business goals and objectives
  • Leadership agreement on, and support for, select improvement projects
  • Project teams staffed for success
  • Project centric training
  • Accountability for timely successful project completion

Include these elements sequentially in the operations improvement plan as your strategy for success.

Performance Metrics tied to business goals and objectives

The leadership team reviews the goals and objectives for the business and selects the performance metrics that measure success. Often, Quality Function Deployment (QFD) or a Prioritization Matrix is used to align and rank the performance metrics with the business goals and objectives. The marching orders are now set for the improvement projects.

Leadership agreement on, and support for, select improvement projects

The leadership team reviews the processes across the supply chain from the beginning to the end. Where are the issues? Where do we fall short of expectations? Where is the waste in the system? These questions drive the brainstorming to identify potential improvement projects. A list is made of the projects and incorporated into another QFD or Prioritization Matrix to align and rank the improvement projects with the rated and ranked performance metrics. Using the matrices keeps the prioritization of the projects aligned with the business goals and objectives.

Project teams staffed for success

The leadership team focuses on the top four or five projects based upon the priorities they have agreed on using prioritization matrices. The teams for these projects are selected from the best and the brightest personnel within the organization that have knowledge or skills relevant to the project. Often these individuals are considered too important or too busy to work on improvements. That is the reason for their selections. These personnel decisions answer the question, “Are you serious about making improvements?”

Project centric training

Each project and its assigned team progress through the Lean Six Sigma training and apply the tools and techniques directly on their improvement opportunity. As quickly as methods are learned they are applied to make progress toward the completion of the project following the train and do philosophy. If the opportunity is a process improvement the methodology follows DMAIC (define, measure, analyze, improve, and control). If the opportunity is a design improvement the methodology follows DMADV (define, measure, analyze, design, and validate), or Design for Six Sigma.

Accountability for timely successful project completion

Success requires the leadership team and the improvement project teams be held accountable to complete the projects in a timely manner. Deliverables based project plans focus the effort of the teams to move through the DMAIC, or DMADV, process phases successfully. Phase exit reviews are held between the project and the leadership teams. Phase exit reviews assure that all parties involved are held accountable to achieve successful strategically focused operations improvement.

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Choosing Hypothesis Tests

A question my students often ask is, “Which hypothesis test should I use and when?” In this article we will address some guidelines to answer the question. The available hypothesis tests are:

  • Continuous Variable Outcomes
    • T Test
    • Paired T Test
    • ANOVA (Analysis of Variance)
    • Test for Equal Variances
  • Discrete Variable Outcomes
    • Chi-Square

The following examples will address which test to use given a certain set of circumstances. In hypothesis testing we are faced with answering the question, “Do the variables in my process make a difference, or not, if they are changed?”

Continuous Variable Outcomes

The output, or outcome, in the process is measured on a continuous scale. We will refer to the outcomes as the “Y”. The input variables, or the things we will be changing, are varied between discrete settings, or levels. The variable could be continuous, but the settings are specific and can be considered discrete.

Case 1: T Test

The T Test allows testing of two items only, or two level settings only. Let’s say we want to improve our gas mileage. The output Y is miles per gallon. The inputs for the T Test are gasoline additives. The level settings could be Yes (use the additive) and No (plain gasoline without additives). The sample size can be small using the T Test. Run 5 tanks of fuel under each condition and measure the miles per gallon. The null hypothesis for this test is regardless of whether or not we use the additive the gas mileage will remain the same evidenced by p values much greater than 0.05. The alternative hypothesis is that there is a difference between Yes and No which is evidenced by p values that are less than or equal to 0.05.

Case 2: Paired T Test

In the Paired T Test only two items can be tested, but the tests are run concurrently, or in pairs of both items. We use the pairing technique when environmental factors may influence the outcomes. We want that “noise” to have an equal chance to affect the test subjects so running the test concurrently assures this equality of noise distribution. In this case, we will test two hull designs for nautical speed. Testing will be carried out over several days so the conditions in the ocean will definitely be changing such as wind speed, wind direction, wave height, and currents. Both of the hull designs will be subjected to the same conditions when we conduct the tests simultaneously in pairs. The plan is to conduct 5 races over the course of one week. If the p values in the Paired T Test are less than or equal to 0.05 than the hull design with the greatest nautical speed can be declared the winner because the test shows a significant difference. If the p value is much greater than 0.05 then we need to go back to the drawing board because there is no difference in the hull designs.

Case 3: ANOVA

Analysis of Variance, or ANOVA, is very powerful because there is essentially no limit to the number of items, or level settings that can be evaluated during the testing. We are limited only by practicality. In this case we want to determine if there is a difference in the distance a golf ball can travel. The outcome Y is the distance in yards. We will test Pinnacle, Nike, Titleist, Srixon, Bridgestone, and Callaway. A robot with one type of golf club will be used to launch the golf balls. Swing speed and force will be the same for each test subject. Twenty of each ball will be launched and the driving distance will be measured. As in all of these hypothesis tests, the p value is the measuring stick for declaring if a difference exists or not. When the p value is < or =" to" style="mso-spacerun:yes"> When the p value is much, much greater than 0.05 we declare that no significant difference exists between the test subjects.

Case 4: Test for Equal Variances

In the three previous cases the concern was a difference in the average value of the outcome based upon the level setting of the input variable. With Test for Equal Variances the evaluation is the variability of the outcomes about the average. The standard deviations are evaluated to test for differences in variation. In this case we will use the data from Case 3, the driving distance of the golf balls. Which golf ball is most consistent in driving distance? If I buy a dozen of these golf balls can I expect the same results? The Test for Equal Variances provides the answer. If the p value is low than the null must go, but if the p value is high the null applies. The null hypothesis is always “There is no difference.” Two tests are used, one is called Bartlett’s Test which requires the distributions to be normally distributed and the other is Levene’s Test which requires only that the data is continuous.

Discrete Variable Outcomes

The output, or outcome, in the process is measured by counting occurrences which is a discrete variable. We will refer to the outcomes as the “Y”. The input variables, or the things we will be changing, are varied between discrete settings, or levels.

Case 5: Chi Square

Chi Square testing compares discrete Y’s and discrete X’s. In this type of analysis categories, or groups, are compared to other categories, or groups. For example, “Which cruise line had the highest customer satisfaction?” The discrete X variables are (RCI, Carnival, and Princess Cruise Lines). The discrete Y variables are the frequency of responses from passengers on their satisfaction surveys by category (poor, fair, good, very good, and excellent) that relate to their vacation experience.

Conduct a cross tab table analysis, or Chi Square analysis, to evaluate if there were differences in levels of satisfaction by passengers based upon the cruise line they vacationed on. Percentages are used for the evaluation and the Chi Square analysis provides a p-value to further quantify whether or not the differences are significant. The overall p-value associated with the Chi Square analysis should be 0.05 or less. The variables that have the largest contribution to the Chi Square statistic drive the observed differences.

Now you should have a good understanding of which hypothesis test to use and when it is most appropriate. Remember that it is just as important to determine that there is no difference as well as that there is a difference. Sound business decisions depend on making choices based on significance.